IdeasCorporate and Commercial

International market, tourism, hotels, restaurants and similar businesses in the 2020 tsunami

Opinion piece written in March 2020, at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, on the effect of the support measures then announced on tourism, hotels and restaurants. Published on the website in July 2021.

Published 7 min readBy ASA Lawyers

A large blue wave breaking at sea, its crest covered in white foam.

In brief

  • Opinion piece written in March 2020, at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, on the international market, tourism, hotels and restaurants.
  • Argues that the support measures then announced did not answer the situation of businesses in these sectors, in particular the requirement to keep teams in place.
  • Proposes that businesses be allowed to assess their viability and adjust their teams, with the workers affected being protected.
  • Anticipates disputes over unperformed contracts, pressure on the courts and a rise in insolvencies.
  • Calls for flexibility and understanding between business owners, workers, landlords and tenants.

Opinion piece published on the website in July 2021; the text was written in March 2020, at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. The measures discussed reflect the law in force at that time and may have changed since.

“There are no lifebuoys that can help us in a tsunami. And we have one ahead of us.”

António Costa – Prime Minister, March 2020

At last, a statement that conveys the real situation we are living through and what the future holds for us over the next four or five months, with an impact on the next decade.

I cannot imagine what it is like to be in the shoes of any political decision-maker at this moment, because these are moments nobody should have to go through, but here we are.

And so, looking at the measures proposed, and with all the sacrifice and work this government has devoted to the situation, they are lifebuoys and, as we already know, lifebuoys do not help us.

But there is one group in particular, given the areas in which our firm, ASA Lawyers, works most – the international market, tourism, hotels, restaurants and similar businesses – and here there is no doubt: the State is throwing them lifebuoys.

Nuno Carvalho of Padaria Portuguesa is right, as are all the others from chains like his, when they are asked to keep their teams for an indefinite time so that they can go back to work once the tsunami has passed.

You do not need to be a fortune-teller to see that even if, on a conservative view, we were able to go out freely again on 1 June, the streets, the people and tourism will not recover, and that means the flow of consumers to the areas that have enriched the country over the last two or three years will not be the same. And what will the picture be on that date? Businesses strangled by keeping on teams which, when activity resumes, still do not have enough work to support them; in all likelihood many will not have managed to renew the simplified lay-off, or will be unable to comply with the condition of not dismissing staff in the period that follows – and will the State then ask for the support to be paid back?

How can employers not be allowed to assess their capacity to support 60, 70 or 150 workers? Room should be given for an analysis of each company’s viability that results in a safer answer for workers: that is, defining the capacity to pay, under lay-off, the team that will be needed for the recovery, while the workers whose positions it would, at this point, make more sense to reduce would be protected by unemployment benefit. Here, yes, the State would be safeguarding the ability of families to support themselves and of businesses in these areas to recover gradually, as part of a balanced process of economic recovery.

By way of comparison, according to the JP Morgan study for the United States, these are the number of days it takes to kill a business with no turnover:

  • Restaurants: 16 days
  • Retail: 19
  • Construction: 20
  • Hairdressers/other services: 21
  • Medical services: 30
  • Media: 27 days

The lifebuoys handed out will kill the possibility of these businesses reinventing themselves and recovering in time for 2021, when tourism and the normal interest of international investment… When we go out again we will find a scene we have witnessed before: commercial premises closed, abandoned, many of them the subject of court disputes, tying up landlords and tenants and making our cities sadder and less fit for the fresh start that sacrifice and hardship have held back.

The health system will fail when we reach the peak between 9 and 15 April, and by that date the economy is certain to fail, because salaries, suppliers, rents and loans will already have become the wave that starts the devastation; and consequently, and possibly with the most lasting impact, the judicial system will fail.

We will spend years arguing over this pandemic as a case of “force majeure”; we will flood the courts with the defaults that result from the inability to meet payments due, to deliver services within a given period, to hand over building works, or to complete final deeds under promissory contracts drawn up at another time, when the parties formed their contractual intention with a scenario such as this far from their minds.

The employment courts … we do not even want to think about it.

And the insolvencies. If there is an invisible monster, COVID-19, which is swallowing us, there is a silent monster growing, which is insolvency, because that is where the path and the State’s support point, and it will possibly be the only lifebuoy left when the tide goes out. It will, unfortunately, be the only chance of a “fresh start” for companies and businesses that were once profitable, but it will mean a very harsh picture in our cities, one that would be unnecessary if the measures taken were “rationalised and not rationed”.

Meanwhile, although people speak of the economy in general, the greatest concern is to save businesses and to manage this situation seriously and realistically, so that families survive and have food to eat and a roof over their heads, because hundreds of thousands of people are being “fed” by the businesses in these areas.

We therefore ask our Prime Minister to review the measures being applied, in a practical way and with real application to the very serious scenario in front of us, and to replace the word deferral with EXEMPTIONS.

We ask our President of the Republic, the President of affections, to address the Nation, not to repeat what the Government already tells us every day, but truly to appeal to affection, to empathy, to cohesion, to the idea that WE ARE ALL ONE – more than staying at home and protecting ourselves and others; indeed, at this point, anyone who does not do that deserves to be locked up. We must be aware that we will all have to give way and lose a little. If business owners all close their doors because they foresee that their normal profit will not be maintained; if workers rush to have all their rights secured and there is no understanding on their side either; if landlords who have always had tenants who paid do not understand that some flexibility now means being able, three months from now, to receive their rents as normal, without having to evict, to claim sums in court, or to put the property back on a market they do not know and which will be very different from B.M.20 (before March 2020).

There is a challenge to be put to people: be reasonable. At the moment we are living through, the only way for the catastrophic scenario I have described not to happen is, in truth, through unity, understanding and flexibility on all sides – all of us having to give way a little so that we do not break. So that, in June, the sectors that have contributed most to the economy in recent years do not close and our cities do not lose their colours: give way, help so that you may be helped.

Even those who have nothing to lose financially – who, on the contrary, are gaining – should contribute at this time. See where you can help: of course, in the first instance, direct financial support should go to the SNS (the national health service), but also to the families whose daily bread is at risk.

Beyond this, if we are all irascible and demand of each other what we would demand in normal times, we will break, and even those who will be very well off financially will see their country in decay, trying for a long time to bring its premises, its shops and its streets back to life.

We have to support each other, because the State only has lifebuoys and the tsunami is here. We cannot shirk our responsibility and, regardless of whether it is the State’s duty to provide Noah’s ark, it will not appear: as the Prime Minister said, there are no miracles.

Be reasonable; let us make our own miracle.

How we can help

Have a question on this subject?

We can look at your particular situation and explain the options open to you. We work in Portuguese and English.

This content is for general information only and is not a substitute for legal advice. It reflects the information available on the date it was published.

Contact

Tell us what you need.

We reply in English or Portuguese, with personal attention to the particulars of each matter.

Phone
+351 215 843 044Call to a Portuguese landline, charged at your provider’s rate
Address
Rua Filipe Folque 10 J, 4.º Esq., 1050-113 Lisboa
Opening hours
Monday to Friday, 09:00⁠–⁠18:00 (Lisbon time)